Print this page

ETF2009 Shootout

The ETF2009 shootout was a contest of single-ended output transformers. Scroll down to see the results and pictures.

 

THE RULES

 

 The test amplifier will be a 310A+300B "l'audiophile" (without negative feedback), and the speaker will have high sensitivity, passive crossover, more or less 8 ohm impedance.

 The shootout listening tests will be MONOPHONIC : there is no need to bring a pair of identical transformers, one is enough.

 The B+ voltage is about 430VDC, and the primary will have to handle 70mA DC.

The negative tap of the secondary will be joined to earth.

 The impedance ratio can go from 2.2K / 8 ohm to 3.6K / 8 ohm.

The test amplifier has 4 female 4mm banana plug (IEC 1010 compatible) :

B+ (high voltage 430VDC) : Red

P (plate of the 300B) : Yellow

0 (earth of the amplifier, and negative input of the speaker) : Black

8 (positive input of the speaker) : White

 

How to register to the shootout ?

  1. First of all, you have to register to the triode festival :  http://www.melaudia.net/subscribeETF.php
  2.  On your registration form, fill the "participate to the shootout with" field with the name of your transformer (brand and reference, or any description if it is a DIY transformer)
  3.  Bring one transformer with the cords+ 4mm banana plug at ETF

 

 

Participants are asked to :

 Make sure that the transformer is not phase-inverting (but it is not disqualifying)

clearly identify each tap that plugs into the test amplifier (color and/or name)

provide 0.5 to 1m cords with 4mm male banana  (IEC 1010 is recommanded)

Pay attention to insulation problems :

  • Please provide B+ / Plate wire with 600VDC insulation at least.
  • If you have any doubt about isolation of your wires on primary side, please add some thermo sleeve around those both.
  • Secondary wire are grounded, so isolation is not an issue.

 

Before the shootout, the following tests will be performed :

  1. a 500V insulation test between B+ and 0 tap.
  2. turn ratio measurement.
  3. phase/out-of-phase check.

 

 

Special stuff :

Parafeed transformers (choke + condensator + transformer without air gap) are authorized.

DIY transformers are especially welcomed, but here again, pay attention to insulation.

mismatchs (5K to 16 ohm, used as 2.5K to 8 ohm, for instance) are authorized, but please indicate clearly which secondary tap you want to plug on the speakers, and which primary tap you want to use.

primary and/or secondary compensations are authorized (zobel network or whatever you want, providing it is not dangerous)

Sorry, negative feedback is forbidden.

 THE SETUP

 

 

Krell CD Transport and Wadia D/A converter

 

The WE310A+WE300B amplifier used for the shootout. There is no output transformer, but two sets of banana female plugs: B+ (red), 300B Plate (yellow), ground (black) and 8 ohm (white). A switch connects the transformer A or B.

 

The mono line preamp used for the shootout. Sowter multitap transformer for the volume, Tango output transformer (500 or 600 ohm external load).

 

 

A 10 turns 500 ohm potentiometer was used to calibrate the output level of each transformer. It is also the external load of the preamplifier.

The loudspeaker used for the shootout : Great Plain Audio 515 and 399, with Westrex acoustilens horn.

 

31 transformers ready for the shoot-out !!!

  

THE RESULTS

 

list of participants :

N° transfo NameType 
29Blöhbaum, FrankPP output transformer, with one primary winding compensating the current of the 300B. 
16Dolinskyi, ArkadiiDIY EI transformer
15Hasling, Per + OleSE Silk transformer from Tailand 3,0 kOhm
1Højbjerg, Karstentoroidal transformer in cardbox
24Hubertse, Robcustom made OPT by AE-Europe.
9Michimori, Hirokuniex-Tango #10887 (special order), rating 50W, 3.5K/4,8,and16ohm,with 360hm KNFB winding
26Monmagnon, YvesDissident audio transformer
14Raudonat, Ralfyes, with output transformer regarding the terms
18Schwarz, Andreasa selfmade single ended output transformer
2Terrell, BrianSE Output transformer
7Veen, van der, Menno toroidal SE-OPT's
11Weidhase, UlfOne Parafeed Transformer 3k5 /8 Ohm Transformer
23Willenswaard, van, PeterAudioNote Trans-300 double-C-core
19Polisois, AristideDIY toroid transformer
13 DIY grey transformer
5Falampin, JérômeUnknown semi-pro vintage transformer (in tea box)
3Bouyer ST10 transformer (in soap box)
21parafeed transformer (9H cheap chinese choke, 1µF cap, 50VA toroid power transformer 220V -> 12V) in biscuit box
25Le Cléac'h, Jean-Michelsmall and old Audionote classA
8Magnetics (special order), 
12 Meigxu (Mingda),
20Tango FX3.5
6Sullerot, JulienPartridge TK 4519
10Tamura transformer from a Sun Audio 2A3 amp
4James JH2123
31Lundahl, PerLL1664AM/70mA
30LL1693/70mA
28Pierre-Francois BrandSpanish transformer
27Pierre-Francois BrandR-core Softone RW-20  : http://www.icl.co.jp/audio/english/RW20.htm
22Weidhase, UlfTransformer
17Weidhase, UlfTransformer

some pictures of the transformers :

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE WINNER

 

Peter van Willenswaard (right) won with an Audionote Trans-300 double-C-core, and receives a pair of TJ 300B from Julien (left).

The measurements

Jean-Michel measuring a transformer. Measurements (distortion, bandwidh, impulse response) have been made with 70mA through the primary.

See the measurements here .


Previous page: ETF 2009 Program
Next page: ETF 2009 photos